Early Look at 2025 Heisman Trophy Picks

The 2025 college football season is just around the corner. Although kickoff is still months away, sportsbooks are already turning their attention to the 2025 Heisman Trophy.

Arch Manning is quickly becoming the frontrunner for the award, but what other players should bettors keep on their radar?

There will be no shortage of Online college football betting as the 2025 college football season approaches.

2025 Heisman Trophy Odds

Arch Manning

Arch Manning, the quarterback for Texas, is currently listed at +600 to win the Heisman Trophy.

As a former top recruit and a potential standout, Manning kicks off the 2025 Heisman race as the clear frontrunner. Frankly, I'm a bit surprised his odds aren't even shorter.

There may still be opportunities to capitalize on this number, even with him leading the pack.

In 2024, Manning completed 68% of his es, amassing 939 ing yards and 13 total touchdowns during his limited playing time.

Arch Manning, and the best team in the SEC return in just 3 months time…

pic.twitter.com/nZDH3pGUUL

— Barstool Longhorn (@UTBarstool) June 2, 2025

When Quinn Ewers returned from his abdominal injury, Manning found himself back on the sidelines.

Nevertheless, many Texas fans believe Manning showed more effectiveness on the field than Ewers in 2024, fueling excitement for the 2025 season.

While the expectation of being a savior is common for highly regarded backup quarterbacks, in Manning's case, the high expectations seem well-founded.

Garrett Nussmeier

Garrett Nussmeier, the quarterback for LSU, currently has odds of +850 to win the Heisman Trophy.

In his inaugural season as the starting quarterback, the junior amassed 4,052 ing yards and 29 touchdowns. While those numbers are impressive, Nussmeier did not necessarily stand out as a true Heisman contender in 2024.

The betting market seems to be banking on a potential breakout in his second year, a trend seen with former LSU Heisman winners like Joe Burrow and Jayden Daniels.

While this is a reasonable approach to betting on the Heisman, the issue lies in the odds.

At +850, the potential return is relatively low for such a significant projection about Nussmeier, which heavily depends on the historical performance of players from previous seasons who are not directly related.

Jeremiah Smith

Jeremiah Smith, the wide receiver for Ohio State, currently has odds of +1000 to win the Heisman Trophy.

In 2024, Smith grabbed attention as a remarkable 17-year-old talent for the Buckeyes, sharing the spotlight with Alabama's Ryan Williams.

Now, as a national champion, the question arises: can he also claim the Heisman?

TWO UNBELIEVEABLE ONE-HANDED CATCHES BY JEREMIAH SMITH 🤯

THEY CAN'T GUARD HIM 👀 pic.twitter.com/vGUUs6rn41

— SportsCenter (@SportsCenter) September 29, 2024

Heisman bettors who favored quarterbacks were left disappointed a few years back when Alabama's DeVonta Smith took home the trophy, spotlighting his own exceptional performance and outshining his quarterback and teammates.

With several top offensive players leaving Ohio State and Smith gaining recognition prior to the season, he is well-positioned to replicate DeVonta Smith’s path to Heisman glory.

Drew Allar

Nittany Lions head coach James Franklin expressed great satisfaction with Allar's development from his first to second year as a starter, suggesting that he could further improve in 2025 if he decides to return for another season.

Allar posted impressive statistics, completing 69.1% of his es for 2,894 yards, along with 21 touchdowns and seven interceptions, while also rushing for six touchdowns.

With Drew Allar, you have a field general under center. Can make pre-snap checks and cue motions. You can execute action rollouts and move the pocket with him. And his easy velocity and angle freedom enables him to layer quick-hitting es when in-rhythm. pic.twitter.com/eV41kNVbat

— Ian Cummings (@IC_Draft) May 5, 2025

With his exceptional arm talent, the Nittany Lions began to leverage his capabilities under offensive coordinator Andy Kotelnicki.

Allar is likely pleased that Kotelnicki chose to remain at Penn State after interviewing for the head coaching position at West Virginia.

We want to ensure you maximize the best bonuses and current promotions. These bonuses can significantly increase your bankroll, allowing you to bet with house money!

Dante Moore

History indicates that Moore, transferring from UCLA, is instantly relevant in the Heisman conversation as the new quarterback for the Ducks.

Oregon quarterbacks have consistently been in the Heisman mix for much of the past two decades.

However, this trend has reached new heights with head coach Dan Lanning and offensive coordinator Will Stein, who have transformed the quarterback position into a breeding ground for Heisman candidates.

Hot Take: This year’s Jayden Daniels, Cam Ward, ect will be Oregon QB Dante Moore

pic.twitter.com/Evbg4r51L6

— Monte (@MONTECRI5TO) May 14, 2025

The last two transfer quarterbacks, Dillon Gabriel and Bo Nix, were both seen as projects in need of revitalization.

Gabriel even held the title of Heisman favorite for several weeks in 2024, while Nix was picked in the first round of the NFL Draft by the Broncos.

Even for those who might doubt Moore, he deserves serious consideration as a Heisman candidate, thanks to the guidance of Lanning and Stein. At +1800 odds, he presents good value.

Similar to how sharps targeted Gabriel's odds in the summer of 2024, I anticipate that Moore will attract attention during the 2025 offseason.

Carson Beck

Carson Beck, the quarterback for Miami (FL), currently has odds of +2800 to capture the Heisman Trophy.

He has garnered significant attention on social media this offseason after transferring to Miami to be closer to his girlfriend, Hanna Cavinder, who plays basketball for the university.

However, the couple has since separated, effectively ending their potential as a standout Gen Z couple before it could even begin.

Despite this, Beck is poised to take over as the starting quarterback for the Hurricanes after Cam Ward. College football fans recognize that Mario Cristobal’s offense has a history of producing Heisman finalists.

The lingering questions for bettors are: Do you still see Beck as a legitimate Heisman contender after the 2024 season?

Are you willing to invest at +2800, or would you prefer to wait for more favorable odds? It certainly seems worth a flier on this longshot.

Check our top sportsbook reviews for the best odds on your favorite NCAA Football games before placing your bets.